1: “I Can’t Put Myself In Her Place”

by | Apr 5, 2021 | Community Stories

In 1988, my wife, Becky, was diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder. Since 1994, when we got married, I’ve been her primary caregiver.

Like many with Bipolar Disorder, she leads an ordinary life. She works. She’s given birth to, and helped raise, two children. She’s buried her mother. In short, she has participated in all of life’s big events. 

Through all the events in our married life, I’ve been alongside her. And I’ve been there for many of the more forgettable moments, too.

I’ve sat beside her in the floor of the laundry room while she sobbed uncontrollably after a friend rang the doorbell. I’ve been there as she admitted herself to a mental hospital for acute care. And, I’ve been there when her mania sent her over the top and she spent 20 hours a day in a flurry of activity.

I say I’ve been there, but in one key way, I haven’t been there.

No matter how much I care for her, no matter how much energy and effort I put in to help her through the inevitable ups and downs, I can’t tell you that I know what she is feeling. I can’t put myself in her shoes.

For any caregiver, that’s a shortcoming we all struggle with. We can take care of the basic needs of running a household or caring for our loved one. But we can’t know what it’s like. In our case, there have been years of conversations in the wake of manic and depressive episodes, in which Becky tells me what she was feeling, what she was thinking. They are painful conversations for her, I am sure. But they help me, as much as I can be helped, to understand what she’s going through.

Still, I can’t really know what she’s thinking in the moment.

I’ve long since stopped trying to find the logic in some of the things she does when she’s in the throes of an episode. It is hard to understand, for instance, what makes a person who hates having their photo taken, stop in the mall on a lark and pose for an expensive Glamour Shots session.

Instead, I’ve learned what actions help her the most and I make sure we take those actions. 

Sometimes that means rest and sleep – lots of it. Other times, it means an unscheduled trip to the doctor. Sometimes it means going places with her to ensure she doesn’t spend money she’ll regret later. 

I’ve come to realize that I won’t ever fully understand the trauma she goes through in the midst of an episode. It’s OK that I can’t put myself in her place. The fact that I can’t means I’m better able to ensure she gets the appropriate care when she needs it because I’m able to think with a clear head when she can’t. 

Understanding that I can’t fully comprehend what she’s going through is actually a big relief for me as a caregiver. I have responsibilities when it comes to helping my wife deal with her diagnosis, but I don’t have to get inside her head.

This is part one of a series of personal entries on being a caregiver, titled “Outside Looking In“.

~ Johnny Whitfield is a former newspaper reporter and editor.

For help, caregivers can turn to organizations like Breaking Taboo, www.breaking-taboo.org, to learn more about their role as a caregiver and how best to help someone with a mental health diagnosis.

Can We Prevent Mental Illness?

We usually talk about mental health after someone is already struggling. After the panic attacks start. After the depression gets heavy. After things fall apart. But what if we asked the question earlier? Mental illness is common, and many conditions begin in the...

How Job-Related Stress Impacts Your Mental Health

For a long time, I treated work stress as just part of being an adult, meeting deadlines, dealing with difficult coworkers, and enduring long days. Many others around me seemed just as tired and overwhelmed, so I assumed that was simply the way things are supposed to...

Teen Dating Violence Awareness Month

Trigger warning: Mentions of dating violence/abuse. When one typically thinks of February, they go straight towards Valentine’s Day or Black History Month. Both events are important aspects of this specific month, offering room for remembrance and appreciation....

The Weight of Winter

2.10.24 Birds must have flown south for the winter. Or wherever the *** it is birds go when thewind and the cold ransack the homes they had nested within the now barren branches. The trees look broken—almost. I didn’t even notice their orange and yellow leaves...

the Correlation Between Poverty and Mental Health

With January now underway, many view it as a fresh start or a period of change. It’s a month when one begins the process of creating new resolutions or vision boards to serve as a direction for the new year. This focus on change fails to take into consideration how...

How to talk to your teenager about suicide prevention

Before reading this article, I would like to provide a trigger warning when discussing the topic of suicide.  The month of September is known to be a time in the year marking the end of summer to transition to the beginning of autumn. It’s a month of change...

the Stigma of Mental Health still Fills the Halls of High School

When some think of high school, they may think of it as one of the happiest times of their lives. High school can be a period of personal growth where one develops self-identity, gains independence, makes lasting friendships, etc. This period in life can shape one’s...

“Bye Bye”: Back-to-School Anxiety & How Parents Can Intervene

As August rolls around each year, it signifies the beginning of a new school year, promising a fresh start to learn and grow with peers. A new school year offers room to make new memories, new friendships, and an opportunity to pursue academic goals. Despite this,...

A Parent’s Guide to Impostor Syndrome

As a parent, there is a great deal of responsibility placed on one to ensure they are the ideal role model for their children to look up to. One has to be mindful of what morals or values they want to instill into their children to emulate. This can be true when...

Scrolling Into Insecurity- Social Media’s effects on Eating Disorders

Up to 95% of adolescents, ages 13-17 years old, report using a social media platform, with more than a third saying that they use social media almost constantly [1]. Social media has become a large part of our lives, and the way it impacts the youth has become a huge...

The Weight of Winter

2.10.24 Birds must have flown south for the winter. Or wherever the *** it is birds go when thewind and the cold ransack the homes they had nested within the now barren branches. The trees look broken—almost. I didn’t even notice their orange and yellow leaves...

the Stigma of Mental Health still Fills the Halls of High School

When some think of high school, they may think of it as one of the happiest times of their lives. High school can be a period of personal growth where one develops self-identity, gains independence, makes lasting friendships, etc. This period in life can shape one’s...

My Synesthesia Causes Me to Hear Colors and Taste Sounds

We all know what our senses are and how we use them every day, but what if you could hear colors and taste sounds? This connection between senses is called Synesthesia, and some people have this complex condition inside their minds. Synesthesia is a mental condition...

The loss of someone you don’t know: How Matthew Perry’s death affected me

I was in elementary school when I first watched an episode of Friends. I was immediately drawn to the character of Chandler. We were both awkward. We were both funny. We both had problems. He was one of my first TV crushes after Shaggy from Scooby-Doo. I became...

Why I’m Involved: An Interview with Crystal Lancaster

I am volunteering at Breaking Taboo because I am extremely passionate about the cause of mental health and working towards ending the suicide epidemic currently facing this country. I myself live with Bipolar 1 Disorder. I had my first mental breakdown when I was 16...

How to Juggle Mental Health With Life: An Interview With Danni Blackman

I was born and raised in Orange County, still currently live in Tustin. Aside from taking care of my mental health at an outpatient facility, I work with my family as an administrative assistant at their law firm and I go to school for Gender Studies and Psychology. I...

Dr. Denise Nguyen Interview: Advice and Experience from a Marriage and Family Therapist

Meet Denise Nguyen.  I was born and raised in Southern California all of my life. I’m a 2nd generation Vietnamese American. My undergrad was through UCI and then received my Masters and Doctorate through Argosy University in Counseling Psychology (MA and EDDCP...

Caitlin Cawley Interview: Staying Strong Against Co-Morbid Mental Illnesses

We had the great pleasure of speaking with Caitlin Cawley. She is someone who shows resilience and fight against many things affecting her mental health. She continues to how one can overcome co-morbid mental illnesses, such as OCD, anorexia nervosa, PTSD, depression...

Surviving Trauma, An Interview with Katie Han

Meet Katie Han, a strong woman who is overcoming her incredible traumas every day. She suffered through childhood abuse and sexual harassment which led to her mood disorders. She shares her insights of how she has learned to love herself, heal, and cope with her...

Amy Chase’s Story of Surviving Abuse and Depression

We enjoyed being able to talk with Amy Chase. She shares her story of emotional and physical abuse, and depression. She has been through a lot since childhood, and is living proof that you can find yourself and heal from your traumas (even at 34 years old.) I wish...

Insights on Anorexia Nervosa & Anxiety by Sierralyn Cadima

We had the pleasure of talking with Sierralyn Cadima, who struggles with generalized anxiety disorder and Anorexia Nervosa. Here, she talks about the steps she has taken to overcome both and her outlook on mental health. Early 2014 when I started seeing a therapist...

How Carla-Rose Overcomes Her Depression & Anxiety

Meet Carla-Rose Smith, a prime example of someone who has been at their lowest of lows and was still able to crawl out of the misery and gain happiness within herself again. Here, she shares her insights about her personal struggle with anxiety and depression, and...

TV’s Dr. Judy Ho on Modern Mental Health

We had the pleasure of chatting with clinical and forensic psychologist Dr. Judy Ho, Ph.D about her career and her thoughts on modern mental health. Dr. Judy is the co-Host of Face the Truth on CBS and Tenured Associate Professor at Pepperdine University. She has a...